Skip to content
Gaming

Is Elden Ring a Cosy Game?

Is Elden Ring a Cosy Game?

Apparently, repeatedly dying to the same boss, losing thousands of runes and getting absolutely humbled by a random enemy is a relaxing way to spend an evening.

At least, that's what my husband seems to think.

We recently got into a debate about whether Elden Ring could actually be considered a cosy game. His argument? It's familiar, repetitive and has a satisfying gameplay loop. Mine? It's a Soulsborne game. A genre practically famous for being brutally punishing. That's about as far from cosy as I can imagine.

But the more we discussed it, the more I realised he might actually have a point. Maybe we're just working with very different definitions of cosy gaming.

Cosy Vibes Only

View all

The Case for Elden Ring Being Cosy

I'll admit, my husband does have a few points.

There's something to be said for the comfort of a game you know inside and out. Once you've spent enough time in the Lands Between, the gameplay starts to feel familiar. You know your favourite routes, where to find certain items, how to tackle particular enemies and which weapons and builds work best for you.

There's a satisfying rhythm to it all. Farm some runes, level up, upgrade your gear, take on a familiar area and repeat. You can spend hours doing essentially the same things, gradually making progress without having to think too hard about what comes next.

And isn't that part of what makes some cosy games so appealing? The repetition, the routines, the familiar little tasks you can get lost in. There's a reason people happily spend hundreds of hours tending to the same virtual farm or rearranging the same little house.

For him, Elden Ring offers that same kind of comfort. It's a world he knows, a gameplay loop he enjoys and something he can pick up whenever he feels like switching off.

I can see the argument. I really can.

The Case Against Elden Ring Being Cosy

But here's where I disagree. And honestly, I think the game gives me plenty of ammunition.

First, there's the difficulty. Soulsborne games are notoriously punishing. They're designed to challenge you, test your patience and occasionally make you question why you even bothered turning the console on. Difficult bosses, unforgiving combat, losing your runes and having to repeat sections you've already worked through are all part of the experience.

But it's not just the difficulty. Have we forgotten just how downright grim the Lands Between actually is?

This isn't a world full of friendly villagers, cute woodland creatures and charming little shops. It's a decaying landscape littered with corpses, grotesque monsters, horrifying creatures and the occasional giant hand with far too many fingers. There are walking mausoleums, horrifying underground areas, enemies that look like they've crawled straight out of a nightmare and enough body horror to keep a horror game enthusiast happy.

No Such Thing as Easy Mode

View all

And then there's the story. If you can piece together what's actually going on, you'll discover a world of betrayal, madness, corruption, tragic deaths and some truly disturbing lore. Almost every character you meet seems to have a miserable existence ahead of them, and getting invested in an NPC's storyline is usually a good way to guarantee something terrible will happen to them.

Even the bosses are a bit much. Between giant monsters, grotesque transformations, blood-soaked battlefields and some genuinely unsettling designs, it's hardly the sort of thing I'd choose when I'm looking for a bit of wholesome escapism.

Cosy games, to me, are about switching off. They're about pottering around, doing a bit of fishing, decorating your house, growing some crops or chatting to your virtual neighbours.

They're not about being chased through a swamp by a giant lobster or stumbling across something so horrifying that you immediately wish you'd stayed at the Site of Grace.

I don't care how familiar the gameplay loop is. There's only so much comfort I can find in a world that looks like it's been designed by someone having a particularly bad day.

Maybe We're Both Right?

I suppose the real question is what actually makes a game cosy.

Is it the art style? The music? The difficulty? The gameplay loop? Or is it simply how a game makes you feel?

My husband seems to find comfort in Elden Ring's familiar routines and repetitive gameplay. For him, it's a satisfying escape where he can switch off and enjoy doing something he knows well.

I still think there's a pretty big difference between mindlessly tending to your virtual vegetable patch and repeatedly getting flattened by Malenia in a world full of dismembered bodies and nightmare fuel.

But perhaps cosy gaming doesn't have to mean cute animals, farming and pastel-coloured cottages. Maybe it's more about finding comfort in a familiar world and a gameplay loop you love, regardless of how challenging (or horrifying) it might be.

I'm still not entirely convinced, though.

So, what do you think? Is Elden Ring a cosy game, or has my husband completely lost the plot?

Previous Post Next Post

Leave A Comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.